Following a lead on a potential serial killer, Saga Anderson and Alex Casey arrive in Bright Falls just as another murder takes place. Leaving their car, they meet up with local police, Deputy Mulligan and Thornton, who review the case with them and show them to the crime scene. After realising that Nightingale had emerged from the lake, Saga heads to the coast to retrace his steps.
Arriving at the Witch's Ladle, they find footprints emerging from the centre of a large tree, as well as a typewritten page. After using her profiling ability on Nightingale, Saga becomes eager to get the body back to town to the mortuary to find out if anything has been placed inside his chest.
As Saga's examination begins, she discovers a manuscript page neatly folded where the heart used to be. Breaker reveals the appearance of similar pages around town but disappears as the light above him flickers. Now awakened, Nightingale sits up and attacks those nearby, stalking the corridors as he finds new victims. Using light to her advantage, Saga is able to recover her service weapon. As she fires, shining her torch beam at him, Nightingale vanishes.
Ties to Later Events
Known by Casey from Quantico, Robert Nightingale was a former FBI agent who mysteriously disappeared thirteen years ago, in 2010. By the time he arrived in Bright Falls, he was no longer working for the bureau; his mental health went into a serious decline following the death of his partner, resulting in Nightingale being fired. Rumoured to have sought refuge from his depression in alcohol, he apparently "chased ghosts until he fell off the map". No one from Bright Falls had heard from or about him following in all this time. Using her profiling, Nightingale reveals that he came from the lake, a place gatekept by a man who grants permission. A manuscript page had been placed inside the hole in his chest.[Profiling: Missing Persons, Ritual Murder, The Page]
The sheriff in Bright Falls, Tim Breaker, took over the role from Sarah Breaker. While his deputies are uneasy by the FBI's presence, Breaker is grateful for the help on the case, sending them casefiles to familiarize themselves ahead of their travel. When asked about the Cult of the Tree, he reveals that he's only familiar with it as an urban legend. There's also information on his childhood; he grew up with Dungeons and Dragons, drawn to playing as magical characters. He had found similar manuscript pages across Bright Falls but vanished in the morgue before giving them to the FBI.
A New York-based writer of true crime, Tammy Brooker came to Bright Falls with Ed as part of her investigation into the disappearance of Alan Wake. They broke into the fenced-off campgrounds with boltcutters to get a closer look at the lake. She was one of the witnesses for Nightingale's emergence from the lake and the crime later at the General Store. After running away, she discovered a necklace from one of the cultists and pocketed it, thinking that the publisher would want to include it on the cover. After getting to safety, she called the police with Ed. Deputy Mulligan and Thorton attended the scene, believing them to be the murderers and threatened to arrest them prior to the FBI's arrival into the town. [Profiling: The Cult of the Tree, Cauldron Lake.]
Ed Brooker
Ed had travelled to Bright Falls with Tammy as part of her investigation into the mysterious disappearance of fellow New York writer Alan Wake. Ed is more forthcoming with the information when interviewed to Saga: that they had witnessed Nightingale emerge from the lake and that later they had seen the cult members stab him. They ran and called the police. After the police's arrival, Deputy Mulligan and Thorton jump to conclusions, wanting to place the Bookers under arrest for the crime. [Profiling: The Cult of the Tree, Cauldron Lake.]
A mysterious writer whose work has been discovered across Bright Falls, including inside Nightingale's chest. He writes about Saga and Casey.
A long-time local show host, Pat Maine is dedicated to his craft and determined to get information into the hands of Bright Falls residents.
Charline
A tired resident who works with Charlie as the Coffee World mascot in front of the docks. She finds her partner's energy amusing.
After learning about the presence of FBI agents in the town, Nelson reveals two minds about recent events: reluctant to allow the investigation to be passed to the FBI and undervaluing their presence, but who also hates that violent crimes have happened in the town. He has an important breakfast bagel he needs to get back to.
Locations & Importance to Chapter
- Cauldron Lake Campgrounds Map. Located on the edge of the car park. Casey calls her over to investigate it.
- Bird Watcher's Journals. Notebooks dropped in a hurry by a visiting birdwatcher.
- Bright Falls Record. The latest issue of the Bright Falls Record can be found abandoned on the trail leading down to the Cauldron Lake General Store.
- Mirror Peak Sign. A signpost along a formerly restricted pathway intended to explain the origins of the location's name.
- Mortar Falls Sign. Close to Witch's Cabin, the sign explains the origins of the location's name.
- (Optional) The Witch's Hut Sign. "The Witch's Hut. Here lived the Witch of Cauldron Lake. Beware - her spirit may still haunt this place."
- Alex Casey Lunch Box (Mortar Falls). "My dad used to say, 'When the going gets tough, the tough get going.' Not sure where the tough get going to, but maybe you'll find it inspiring."
- Alex Casey Lunch Box (Witch's Cabin). "I know things can get a little crazy around here, but if you're ever feeling scared, just remember that ALAN is watching over us."
- Camp Ground Journal. An abandoned journal left by a teenager who plans to explore a building close to the lake.
- Crate Stash (Crime Scene). Discover the first crate hidden by The Cult of The Tree.
- Cauldera Conspiracy. Pages from a notebook detailing how the caldera is manmade.
- Witch's Ladle Sign.
- Deer Head (Crime Scene). Just south of the crime scene (using the map), there's an abandoned house. Go inside the living room to find your first deer head.
- Witch's Ladle Sign. A sign explaining the folklore behind the large tree, the Witch's Ladle.
- Alex Casey Lunch Box (FBC Station). Located on the far side of the FBC Station.
- Elderwood Palace Lodge Sign. A long-standing lodge, the building was brought into the centre of Bright Falls log by log in 2016.
- Pat Maine Radio. Eager to learn more about the weather for the Deerfest week, Maine reluctantly consults a local metrologist's uncle, Tapio.
- Bright Falls Map. Discovered inside the Elderwood Palace Lodge, to the right of the door as you enter.
- Casey's Casenotes. A three-step plan for what to do as they begin the investigation.
- "Setter is Better" Mayoral Sign. Discovered just outside Clay's Clam House.
- Deer Head (Elderwood Palace Lodge). Located on the wall inside the Elderwood's Palace Lodge's private room, just off from the dining area.
- Broken Jukebox. After multiple playthroughs of Coconut, the faithful Oh Deer Diner jukebox has called it a day.
- Deer Head (Oh Deer Diner). Break into the "Employee Only" door at the back of the diner to discover another deer head.
- Toilet Paper Debate. Theft of the toilet paper at the Bright Falls Sheriff Station is taken with a high degree of seriousness.
- The Message (collected inside the Overlap)
- Saga Fights Nightingale with Light (After Chapter 1)
- Saga Persues Nightingale (After Chapter 1)
- Saga Anderson's Deja Vu (The Final Draft)
- Alex Casey. Prior to the events of the original game, Alex Casey is the name of the fictional detective who starred in Alan Wake's best-selling book series.
- Driving Through The Forest. Alan Wake 2 starts similar to its predecessor. After the Prologue, Saga drives down the forest roads to get to Cauldron Lake. The camera angles mirror those used in the opening scene in Alan Wake, with the writer eagerly speeding around the curving roads to reach the lighthouse.
- Unbearable Death. After the deputy that Saga was expecting to meet doesn't show in the car park, Casey makes the suggestion that he was perhaps eaten by a bear. Death by Bear jokes aren't uncommon in Alan Wake. In the original game, prompted by his wife, Alan reluctantly lets Alice take a photo of him on the ferry to Bright Falls. He suggests a title for the piece "City Boy Moments Before He Got Eaten By A Bear".
- Recurring Characters. Although heard in passing or in radio interviews, Deputy Mulligan and Thornton are characters from the original game. Pat Maine is still the local radio show host. Rose Marigold still tends to the Oh Deer Diner. Nightingale is an obvious recurring character, having last seen him in the shadows during Deerfest. While Sarah Breaker has moved on from her position of sheriff, Tim Breaker has taken her place.
- Folklore. In Saga's room, there's a book called "North American Folklore". In Alan Wake's American Nightmare, Scratch was rumoured to come into being following urban legends surrounding the returning writer. In Alan Wake 2, many of the characters have become more embedded in folklore, including Barbara Jagger, who appears in The Witch's Ladle.
- Oh Deer Diner Changes. In the original game, Alan checks in on Stucky, who has visited the bathroom. After knocking, he's interrupted by Barbara Jagger, who has his keys and directions to his cabin. While players don't enter the bathroom during the main game, they do during The Signal DLC. The room's layout has changed to a multi-gender facility to make way for the converted office next to it.
- Sherrif Station Changes. While on the surface, the station has remained the same, there are some significant changes; the old Sherrif's office has been moved and replaced by stairs leading down to the mortuary in the basement. Another change is that the jails have been made bigger.
- Don't Touch The Bear. In the corner of the Oh Deer Diner, Saga can discover the cardboard bear used in the Koskela Brothers adverts, specifically the one punched in the face during their tour campaign.
- Sherrif Station Changes. On the development side, the jails may have been altered compared to the original game for two important narrative reasons. First, for FBC material to be brought in and secured later in the game. Second, to allow greater space for the later boss battle with Mr Scratch.
- Alex Casey. Alan Wake later learns that Alex Casey wasn't a character he created, but he had unknowingly based on the real detective.
- Coffee. Both Saga and Casey take sips of coffee at the same time, like their concept counterparts seen in Quantum Break's Return teaser.
- Order of the FBC. The site around Cauldron Lake was closed by order of the FBC. If Saga tries to use the intercom, they will reveal that they've had issues, eluding to the Hiss takeover in Control.
- Gaping Maw. If left to go into idle dialogue, Saga and Casey talk about the area being a caldera. Casey clarifies that it's then the "gaping maw of hell", a description similar to Max Payne's description of the past as "a gaping hole" but with the connections of the hole being alive and hungry.
"The Case Board is a mental technique that allows Saga to analyze clues and progress the investigation.
- [Linked to Victims] Ted Lane. "Dentist. Stab wounds, bloating, bruising on the wrists." Highlighted the text reads, "The victim was reported missing in 2010. Discovered in 2012, buried in a shallow grave".
- [Linked to Victims] Wendy Davis. "Teacher. Body bloated, large chest wound." Highlighted the text reads, "Found in Cauldron Lake, 2018. Some organs missing - Predation? State of the body does not match eight years spent in a lake."
- [Linked to Victims] Percy Wolfe. "Store owner. Bruising, heart removed, strange tattoos." Highlighted the text reads, "Found 2 weeks ago. Chest wound was ruled as cause of death. Tattooing on the body is illegible."
- [Linked to Crime Scene Photo] "Bruising on wrists and legs". Highlighted the text reads, "Two of the victims had bruising - some form of restraint? Strapped or belted down?" Photo 696-56535.
- [Linked to Crime Scene Photo] "Deep gash in the chest, heart missing." Highlighted the text reads, "Most recent victim died of major chest trauma. Consistent with 2018 victim? Hard to confirm due to condition of body." Photo 696-56557.
- [Linked to Crime Scene Photo] "All bodies experienced bloating." Highlighted the text reads, "Bloating of the corpse is indicative of drowning, but only one victim was found in water." Photo 696-56545
- [Linked to Crime Scene Photo] Post-mortem tattooing of the body. Highlighted the text reads, "Victim #3 was covered in illegible tattoos. A message from the killer, maybe? Or their 'art'." Photo 696-56538
- [Linked to Crime Scene Photo] The murder targets have no discernable common traits. Highlighted, the text reads, "Apart from going missing in 2010, the victims have nothing apparent in common." Photo 696-56589.
- [Linked to Crime Scene Photo] "Chest trauma resembles animal butchery techniques." Highlighted, the text reads, "Chest trauma resembles animal butchery techniques." Photo 696-56589
(Unlocks following examining the crime scene, talking to Casey,
- [Linked to Consistent With Previous Murders] Major Chest Trauma. "This is consistent with previous killings."
- [Linked to Consistent With Previous Murders] Heart found near victim's body. "Heart was removed, but then left on the table near the body. Was this murder interrupted...?"
- [Linked to Consistent With Previous Murders] Cargo straps used to restrain victim. "Brusing indicates victim was alive when restrained. Matches other cases."
- [Linked to The Victim?] Thorton: Victim is Robert Nightingale. Last seen in Bright Falls 13 years ago. "No one's heard from this guy in 13 years. Why surface now? Where's he been?" Unlocked after talking to Thornton
- [Linked to The Victim?] Casey: Nightingale went off the deep end. FBI fired him. "I trust Casey's read on people. Sounds like our victim wasn't mentally stable." Unlocked after talking to Casey,
- [Linked to The Killer(S)?] Heavy blood splatter on table. "They really made a mess, here. Caught up in the act or just sloppy work?"
- [Linked to The Killer(S)?] Multiple sets of footprints. "Lots of activity here. It's unlikely our killer was working alone."
- [Linked to The Killer(S)?] Tripod found near body. "Looks new. Brought by the killers. Why? To mount a camera? Weird snuff film...?"
- [Linked to The Killer(S)?] Cooler and beer bottles left nearby. "Lots of activity here. It's unlikely our killer was working alone."
- [Linked to Victim Came From...?] Nightingale came from Cauldron Lake. "I can feel that Nightingale came from the lake. But why now, after 13 years? Where has he been?"
- [Linked to Victim Came From...?] Trail has gone cold. "A dead end. Literally." Unlocked after initially examining the Overlap.
- [Linked to Victim Came From...?] Footprints emerging from under the rock. "What? He walked through a boulder? Doesn't make sense." Unlocked after initially examining the Overlap.
- [Linked to Victim Came From...?] Nightingale has something hidden inside of him "There's more going on here than I'm seeing. I need to examine this body properly back in town." Unlocked after profiling Nightingale with The Page.
- [Linked to Victim Came From...?] Reading the words, these words, felt like a message. Somone laying a game with them. "So the killer is watching us? Game on." Unlocked after collecting the manuscript page from The Overlap.
- [Linked to Ritual Writing?] Smudged text under victim's skin? "Is this some kind of tattoo? It's too smudged to read.
- [Linked to Ritual Writing?] Illegible word on heart? "Did the killers write this on the heart? How? I can't make out what it says.
- [Linked to Cause of Death?] Smudged text under victim's skin? "Is this some kind of tattoo? It's too smudged to read.
- [Linked to Cause of Death?] Bruises, defensive wounds on victim. "Looks like Nightingale put up a fight before they restrained him"
- [Linked to Cause of Death?] Bloating of joints indicates long-term water exposure. "Victim was alive when strapped down. Timeline is inconsistent with bloating."
- The Shining. Influenced by Stephen King works such as The Shining, Alan Wake used similar sweeping camera movements shown in the film when following a car journey. The same can be seen as Saga and Alex arrives to town.
- Twin Peaks. The series was a huge inspiration for the team in the original game, with aspects of it carrying over into the sequel. Similar to the pilot episode, the story focuses on an FBI agent called into town to investigate a murder.
In Invitation, players are introduced to two leading characters: Saga Anderson (played by Melanie Liburd) and Alex Casey (played by Sam Lake and voiced by James McCaffrey). For both Lake and McCaffrey, it was a return to the role of sorts, both having played the lead in Max Payne; Lake was the physical actor, and McCaffrey provided the voice.